Homemade Fermented Pickle Recipe | The Prairie Homestead (2024)

Homemade Fermented Pickle Recipe | The Prairie Homestead (1)

I’m out of control, you guys…

Since my foray into homemade sauerkraut earlier this year, I’m now on a kick to ferment everything…

I have to admit, it helps that I’m no longer scared of the whole process, and have learned that fermented foods don’t taste gross– as long as they are done right.

My homemade fermented ketchup boosted my confidence even further, so I hunted down some pickling cucumbers at the Farmer’s Market (the ones in my garden aren’t ready yet…) and have dove head-first into the salty world of old-fashioned brined pickles.

And my oh my, I am so glad I did.

But first, in case you’re wondering about the whole brined pickles vs. fermented pickles vs. vinegar pickles thing, here’s a quick run-down:

Homemade Fermented Pickle Recipe | The Prairie Homestead (2)

Three Ways to Make Pickles

  • Fermented/Brine Pickles: These are the ones we’re making today. Fermented pickles rely on good old-fashioned salt and beneficial bacteria to make things happen. The best part about a fermented pickle recipe? It’s easy to make as little (or as much) as you need, and they are packed-full of probiotic benefit.
  • Vinegar Refrigerator Pickles: These guys are also simple to make, however, they will be lacking in the probiotic department. Instead of using the fermenting process, refrigerator pickles rely on vinegar for that traditional pickle tang. Learn more about quick pickles and find a great brine recipe in my article here.
  • Traditional Canned Vinegar Pickles: I’ve made a whole lotta canned pickles in my preservation career thus far. The benefits of canned pickles is that you can put up big batches at once and they will be shelf-stable for long periods of time. The downside? The high-temps ruin any beneficial bacteria and a lot of the nutrients. They can also be mushy if you aren’t careful. Check out my 5 Best Tips for Crispy Crunchy Pickles before you can your pickles for some ideas on how to prevent mushy home-canned pickles.

Why Use an Airlock Fermenting System?

Airlocks make the fermenting process even more fool-proof (especially for beginners) by reducing the the chance of mold, and allowing the ferment to release gases without you having to “burp” it. Can you ferment without an airlock? Sure, but to me, an airlock seems like cheap insurance for a better end result.

There are a number of air lock systems out there, but I’ve been lovingthe Fermentools system.It fits right onto mason jars so I don’t have to buy a bunch of special jars, and it makes it easy to makebigbatches (I did several 1/2 gallon jars with this pickle recipe, and it didn’t take any extra work or equipment to make it happen). I’ve been working with Matt from Fermentools for a while now and he’s been totally helpful as I’ve navigated my first adventures into fermenting.

Homemade Fermented Pickle Recipe | The Prairie Homestead (3)

Fermented Pickle Recipe

You will need (per quart jar):

  • Small pickling cucumbers*
  • 1-2 cloves garlic
  • 1 tablespoon mustard seed
  • 10 peppercorns
  • 1 bay leaf
  • 1-2 heads of fresh dill (or 1 tablespoon dill seed, if you prefer)
  • Sea salt and water to make 2% brine solution (instructions below)

*It might be tempting to try to use the larger, slicing cucumbers to make pickles, but don’t. They are mostly water and will give you a mushy, limp result. Your local farmer’s market should have loads of pickling cucumbers if you can’t grow them yourself, and you’ll be glad you went to the extra trouble to find them. Here are my best tips for keeping your pickles super crunchy.

How to Make 2% Brine:

Dissolve 1 tablespoon fine sea salt in 4 cups non-chlorinated water. If you don’t use all of the brine for this recipe, it will keep indefinitely in the fridge.

I always use sea salt for my brines, but kosher salt or canning salt will work too. Just avoid iodized salts (learn why in my Cooking with Salt article).

The finer the salt, the less stirring you must to do to dissolve, which is niiiiiiice.

The Fermented Pickle Recipe:

Start with very clean jars.

Add the garlic, mustard seed, peppercorns, bay leaf, and dill to each jar.

Homemade Fermented Pickle Recipe | The Prairie Homestead (4)

Wash your cucumbers thoroughly and discard any that are mushy or soft. Remove the blossom end from each cucumber, and pack them into the jars. I prefer to leave my cucumbers whole, as it seems to give a crunchier end result.

Cover the cucumbers completely with the 2% brine solution.

Homemade Fermented Pickle Recipe | The Prairie Homestead (5)

Add a weight to the jar to keep the cukes from floating to the top. (I use the handy glass weights from Fermentools, but you can get creative with whatever you have on hand.)

Add the air lock assembly (or regular lid if that’s what you’re using), and set aside to ferment at room temperature for 5-7 days. Keep in mind, the warmer your kitchen, the faster the fermenting process.

After the initial fermenting process is over, remove the airlock, cover with a regular lid, and store at 32-50 degrees for up to six months. (I’m keeping mine in my fridge.) The pickles will continue to slowly ferment and improve in flavor during the storage process. After about six months, they will start to slowly degrade, but will absolutely still be edible. However, I’m betting they’ll be long-gone before then.

Homemade Fermented Pickle Recipe | The Prairie Homestead (6)

Fermented Pickles: What’sNormal?

Your fermented pickles might look a little bit different than the home-canned pickles you’re used to.

Here’s what to expect:

  • Cloudy brine, often getting cloudier as time progresses.
  • Fizziness! Fizzy pickles are totally normal and just a sign things are working as they should.
  • Liquid leaking out of the jar. Again, this is a normal process of fermentation. However, you can sometimes avoid it by making sure you don’t add too much brine to your jars.
  • Lots of bubbles = happy pickles
  • Pleasant sour taste. Fermented pickles have a slightly different tang than vinegar pickles. However, my kiddos are still gobbling them up.

If your ferments ever end up with a disgusting or putrid smell, that’s a good indication to toss them.

Homemade Fermented Pickle Recipe | The Prairie Homestead (7)

Homemade Fermented Pickle Recipe | The Prairie Homestead (8)

Fermented Pickle Notes:

  • Want to keep things super simple? You can ditch everything in this recipe but the cucumbers and brine. Seriously! That’s the best thing about pickles– tailor them to your taste preferences and what spices you have on hand.
  • Want super-crunchy pickles? Follow the tips in this post.
  • My Fermentools airlocks makes it super easy to make larger batches of pickles– especially in my half-gallon jars. However, if you only have a handful of cukes, you can still jar them up to ferment in small batches.
  • Can I use whey in my ferments? Yes, some folks use raw whey in their fermented vegetable recipes to jump-start the fermenting process. However, I haven’t found whey to be necessary, and I like the flavor a simple salt brine brings to a recipe.

More Fermented Food Recipes & Tips:

  • How to Use a Fermenting Crock
  • Fermented Ketchup Recipe
  • Pickled Green Beans Recipe
  • How to Make Sauerkraut
  • How to Make Dairy Kefir
  • How to Make Kombucha

Where to Buy Fermenting Stuff?

I’ve been totally impressed with myFermentoolsequipment. Here’s why:

  • The airlocks work with the jars I already have.
  • You can easily make big batches of fermented foods with little hassle (no lugging around heavy crocks, either)
  • Their glass weights are super nice to justpop into my mason jars so the food doesn’t float out of the brine and get gross.
  • There’s a super-handy chart on the front of their ultra-fine powdered salt bags to help you figure out exactly how much you need for the perfect brine

Shop the online store at Fermentools HERE.

Homemade Fermented Pickle Recipe | The Prairie Homestead (10)

This post is sponsored by Fermentools, which means they sent me one of their air lock systems so I could try it out. However, like everything I promote here on The Prairie Homestead, I don’t promote it unless I’m actually using it and loving it, which is absolutely the case here.

Homemade Fermented Pickle Recipe | The Prairie Homestead (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Francesca Jacobs Ret

Last Updated:

Views: 6086

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (68 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Francesca Jacobs Ret

Birthday: 1996-12-09

Address: Apt. 141 1406 Mitch Summit, New Teganshire, UT 82655-0699

Phone: +2296092334654

Job: Technology Architect

Hobby: Snowboarding, Scouting, Foreign language learning, Dowsing, Baton twirling, Sculpting, Cabaret

Introduction: My name is Francesca Jacobs Ret, I am a innocent, super, beautiful, charming, lucky, gentle, clever person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.