Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (2024)

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (1)

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Ultimate Guide

Anna Maria Island, located on Florida’s Gulf Coast, is one of my favourite places in the entire world!

This little slice of paradise boasts pristine beaches, a tranquil ambiance, and charming coastal vibes. However, it’s not just made for beach lovers, but is also a haven for coffee enthusiasts too!

In this blog, we’ll explore the very best places to get coffee on Anna Maria Island, including the top spots to people watch and experience the laidback island vibes. Trust me when I say you don’t want to miss any of these spots!

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (2)

Best Coffee Spots on Anna Maria Island:

1. Ginny’s & Jane E’s

Ginny’s & Jane E’s is a beloved island institution and it’s not just about the coffee; it’s the experience! This quirky café and bakery is one of the best coffee spots on Anna Maria Island, especially if you’re looking to take in the sunshine and watch the world go by. What makes this place so special? Well, it’s a combination of its warm and welcoming atmosphere, with coffee that’s brewed to perfection. Here you can enjoy your coffee amidst vintage decor and a collection of eclectic items, from antique furniture to local art. I just LOVE the vibe here.

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (3)

2. The Donut Experiment

What pairs perfectly with a cup of coffee? Freshly made, customisable donuts, of course! This makes the Donut Experiment one of the best places to grab a coffee on Anna Maria island! When you get here, simply choose your toppings and watch as they create a donut masterpiece right in front of you. Pair your artisanal donut with a freshly brewed cup of coffee for an unforgettable breakfast experience.

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (4)

3. Anna Maria Island Coffee Shack

For those who appreciate a good pour-over or single-origin coffee, Anna Maria Island Coffee Shack is the best place for coffee on Anna Maria Island. Located in Holmes Beach, right across from Keyes Marina, this coffee haven takes its craft seriously. They source premium beans and offer a variety of brewing methods to satisfy even the most discerning coffee connoisseurs.

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (5)

4. North Shore Cafe

Nestled in the heart of Anna Maria Island, you’ll find the cozy North Shore Café. Here, you can savour a delightful cup of coffee along with a variety of fabulous breakfast options. My favourite thing about this place is the diverse range of coffee, specialty teas, and refreshing acai bowls available. For anyone traveling with little ones, be sure to check out their gourmet popsicles, which are super popular with the kids. There’s something about this charming Anna Maria Island coffee shop that keeps people coming back year after year. To remember your beach vacation, don’t forget to explore their quaint store and pick up a souvenir or two at this great local coffee shop.

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (6)
Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (7)

5. Two Scoops

Two Scoops is a great place to get coffee on Anna Maria Island, as it offers a unique experience not often found in traditional coffee shops. Beyond serving delicious ice cream treats, Two Scoops has lots of breakfast and lunch options, along with a selection of coffee beverages. Whether you’re in the mood for a quick meal, your fave coffee, or a scoop or two of ice cream, this place provides a one-of-a-kind experience that sets it apart from typical coffee shops on Anna Maria Island.

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (8)
Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (9)

6. Cool Beans A.M.I.

”Coffee means more to us than just a beverage.” This statement perfectly captures the deep appreciation that the owners of Cool Beans’ have for coffee and their dedication to the craft. While relatively new on Anna Maria Island, Cool Beans has swiftly earned a special place in the hearts of locals. The establishment proudly serves a variety of coffee sourced from regions like Colombia, Ethiopia, Guatemala, and Honduras, with a steadfast commitment to offering only organic and fair-trade options. In addition to traditional offerings, Cool Beans also provides vegan and CBD-infused choices. Guests can enjoy their coffee outdoors, overlooking the scenic City Pier and Tampa Bay. For me, what sets this cafe apart and makes it one of the best coffee shops on Anna Maria Island is Cool Beans’ commitment to community, with its unique selection of products from local artists and vendors.

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (10)
Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (11)

7. Fifty Three Fifty, The Pour House

Having grabbed both breakfast and dinner here, I can attest that this Coffee and Wine bar has some great food options. From their Brown Sugar Banana French Toast to their Grouper Sandwich the food here is seriously tasty! However, what really makes this local business stand out is their coffee – they offer custom options on lattes where you can get your photo or image on the foam of the coffee! How amazing! I would definitely recommend checking this place out if you’re in the area for a coffee or want some good food.

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (12)

8. Back Alley Treasures

Whether you’re in the mood for a keepsake or a good old cup of coffee, Back Alley Treasures is your one-stop shop! This local favourite is proudly owned and operated by a tight-knit family who grew up vacationing on Anna Maria Island… but fate took an intriguing turn when they stumbled upon the opportunity to acquire Back Alley! They seized the moment, and it’s proved to be a fortuitous decision. Today, Back Alley Treasures offers some of the best coffee on Anna Maria Island, serving a range of beloved café classics. Whether you crave the simplicity of their medium roast house blend or are after something more distinctive like a blended frappe, they have it all. What’s more, you can choose your preferred milk, all at no extra charge!

This local company also has some amazing smoothies on the menu, including boozy smoothies, which is pretty unique. Inside the gift shop, Back Alley Treasures has an eclectic range of souvenirs sourced from local artisans and talented people from around the world. Every item is a testament to the passion of small businesses and independent artists, making your purchases a way to support these creative minds. It’s a win-win scenario!

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (13)
Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (14)

9. Anna Maria Island Beach Café

When it comes to the best coffee on Anna Maria Island, this gorgeous little Beach Café should be on your list. Here, you’ll discover a well-stocked coffee bar and lots of other treats, including tropical co*cktails, ice cream, and classic American lunchtime faves like burgers and tuna sandwiches, which you can enjoy with stunning beachside views.

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (15)

10. Starbucks

For those who favour household names, you’ll find a Starbucks conveniently located in nearby Bradenton, which is on the mainland just east of Anna Maria Island. So you won’t have to venture too far from your hotel to enjoy your usual coffee ritual! No matter your holiday plans, beginning your day with a delightful cup of coffee is a must! Although I highly recommend trying some local coffee too, while you’re here!

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (16)
Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (17)

Best Activities Anna Maria Island

There’s more to Anna Maria Island than coffee, so once you’ve had your caffeine fix, why not check out some of the best things to do here?

Here’s my list of all the best activities on Anna Maria Island:

🟣 Relax on the Beaches

Anna Maria Island boasts pristine, white-sand beaches with clear Gulf of Mexico waters. In 2015, Anna Maria Beach was actually ranked as the fourth-best beach in the United States by TripAdvisor! Spend your days sunbathing, swimming, building sandcastles, or strolling along the shore.

🟣 Water Sports

There are tons of water sports to enjoy here! Try kayaking, paddle boarding, windsurfing, or even parasailing. You can also rent jet skis, go fishing, or take a scenic boat tour to explore the coastline and its amazing wildlife.

🟣 Visit Historic Piers

Anna Maria Island has several historic fishing piers, including the Anna Maria City Pier and the Rod & Reel Pier, which offer some excellent fishing opportunities and incredibly scenic views. Best of all, they are totally free to visit!

🟣 Explore Bean Point

This secluded beach at the northern tip of the island is a local favourite. Bean Point offers fantastic views, calm waters for swimming, and is a perfect spot for watching the sunset.

🟣 Anna Maria Island Historical Society Museum

Learn about the island’s fascinating history, culture, and heritage at this small but informative local museum. It’s a great way to gain insight into the island’s past and I thoroughly recommend adding this place to your Anna Maria Island itinerary!

🟣 Shop and Dine

Visit the charming shops and boutiques on Pine Avenue in Anna Maria or explore the dining scene with tons of seafood restaurants, cafes, and ice cream shops to choose from.

🟣 Biking and Golf Carts

Rent a bicycle or a golf cart to explore the island at a leisurely pace. The island is small and relatively flat, making it perfect for biking.

🟣 Wildlife Watching

Anna Maria Island is home to a variety of wildlife, including dolphins, manatees, sea turtles, and a wide range of bird species. Don’t forget your binoculars for birdwatching! This is for sure one of the best things to do on Anna Maria Island.

🟣 Art Galleries

Discover local art at the island’s galleries, such as the Island Gallery West, showcasing some incredible paintings, sculptures, and more.

🟣 Day Trip to Nearby Islands

Consider taking a day trip to nearby islands like Longboat Key, Siesta Key, or Sarasota to explore more of Florida’s Gulf Coast.

🟣 Attend a Yoga Class

Many yoga studios on the island offer beachfront classes, allowing you to relax and rejuvenate while enjoying the natural surroundings.

🟣 Sip your fave brew, of course!

Of course no trip is complete without trying some of the best coffee on Anna Maria Island!

Remember that the pace on Anna Maria Island is laid-back, so take the opportunity to unwind and appreciate the island’s beauty and charm. Whether you’re seeking relaxation or adventure, Anna Maria Island has something for everyone.

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (18)
Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (19)

Fun Facts about Anna Maria Island

Here’s some fun facts about Anna Maria Island because why not?!

🔶 No High-Rises

One of the most distinctive features of Anna Maria Island is its strict building codes that prohibit high-rise buildings. As a result, most accommodations are low-rise, giving the island a quaint and charming atmosphere, which is quite an achievement in this modern and overly commercialised world. The island is also relatively small, measuring just 7 miles in length, making it an intimate and cozy destination.

🔶 No Chain Hotels

You won’t find any large chain hotels on Anna Maria Island. Instead, accommodations consist of smaller resorts, vacation rentals, and boutique inns, which I think is totally refreshing.

🔶 Limited Chain Stores

Anna Maria Island prides itself on its locally owned and operated businesses. You won’t find any chain restaurants or fast-food outlets here. I seriously love this initiative!

🔶 Turtle Nesting

The island is known for its sea turtle nesting sites. Loggerhead, green, and even occasional leatherback sea turtles come ashore to lay their eggs on the island’s beaches. How adorable! The absence of streetlights on the island is deliberate to protect the sea turtles nesting on the beaches. During nesting season, turtle-friendly lighting is used instead.

🔶 “The Greenest Little Main Street in America”

Anna Maria City on the island is often referred to as “The Greenest Little Main Street in America” because of its lush landscaping and cute shops.

🔶 Eco-Friendly

The island has a strong commitment to sustainability and environmental preservation. Efforts are made to protect wildlife and maintain the natural beauty of the area, which is another reason why I love this place so much!

🔶 Manatee Avenue

One of the main roads on the island is named Manatee Avenue, which reflects the presence of the gentle sea creatures (manatees) in the area’s waters. So, keep your eyes peeled for these creates while your here, they are soooo cute!

I think these fun little facts add to Anna Maria Island’s unique character and charm, making it a beloved destination for both residents and visitors seeking a picturesque escape.

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (20)

Where to stay on Anna Maria Island?

Anna Maria Island offers a range of great accommodation options to suit different preferences and budgets. The area is known for its quaint and unique accommodations, including boutique inns, beachfront cottages, and vacation rentals.

Best Areas:

When you visit Anna Maria Island, I recommend staying in one of these locations:

🏝️ Anna Maria City

This charming town is located at the northern end of the island and offers a quieter atmosphere. You’ll find plenty of beachfront cottages, vacation rentals, and boutique inns here.

🏝️ Holmes Beach

Situated in the middle of the island, Holmes Beach offers a mix of accommodations, including beachfront resorts, condos, and rental homes. It’s also close to some excellent shopping and dining options.

🏝️ Bradenton Beach

Located at the southern end of the island, Bradenton Beach is known for its lively atmosphere and beachfront accommodations. You can find resorts, rental condos, and beachfront hotels here.

Top tip: It’s a good idea to book well in advance, especially during the peak tourist season, to make sure you get the accommodations that best suit your needs.

Best Accommodations:

Here’s some of the best places to stay on Anna Maria Island:

🛌🏻 Waterline Villas & Marina, Autograph Collection

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (21)
Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (22)

This upscale resort in Holmes Beach offers comfortable accommodations with a coastal chic vibe. It has everything you need, including a marina, beach club access, a pool, and an on-site restaurant.

🛌🏻 Anna Maria Island Inn

Situated in Bradenton Beach, this charming inn offers Gulf-front rooms with private balconies. It’s within walking distance of shops and restaurants.

🛌🏻 Cedar Cove Resort & Cottages

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (23)
Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (24)

Located in Holmes Beach, this resort features beachfront cottages and tropical gardens. It’s a tranquil and secluded option for those seeking peace and privacy.

🛌🏻 The Island Beach Club

This beachfront condo complex in Holmes Beach offers fully equipped units with Gulf views. It’s a great choice for families or groups.

🛌🏻 Tropic Isle Beach Resort

Located in Bradenton Beach, this charming resort offers a mix of rooms and apartments, many with kitchenettes. It has a heated pool and a tropical courtyard.

Keep in mind that the island’s unique charm lies in its boutique accommodations and relaxed atmosphere, making it a perfect destination for those seeking a peaceful and coastal getaway.

🛌🏻 Seaside Inn Beach Resort

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (25)
Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (26)

Situated in Bradenton Beach, this resort offers a range of accommodations, including motel rooms and apartments. It has a heated pool and is just steps from the beach.

Best time to visit Anna Maria Island

The best time to visit Anna Maria Island largely depends on your preferences when it comes to weather, crowds, and activities.

Here’s a breakdown of what to expect during the different seasons:

🏝️ Winter (December to February)

This is the peak tourist season on Anna Maria Island. The weather is mild and pleasant, with daytime temperatures in the 70s°F (20-25°C). It’s the perfect time for beachgoers, water sports enthusiasts, and those looking to escape cold northern winters. However, it’s also the most crowded and expensive time to visit!

🏝️ Spring (March to May)

Spring offers warm and pleasant weather with temperatures in the 70s and 80s°F (20-30°C). It’s a great time for outdoor activities, and the island is less crowded than in the winter months. Spring break can be busy, so be sure to plan accordingly.

🏝️ Summer (June to August)

Summer on Anna Maria Island brings hot and humid weather with temperatures often reaching the 90s°F (30-35°C)! This is the hurricane season in Florida, so there’s a higher chance of rain and storms. However, it’s a good time for budget travellers, as accommodation prices are lower, and you can enjoy the beautiful Gulf waters.

🏝️ Fall (September to November)

Fall weather remains warm, with temperatures in the 70s and 80s°F (20-30°C). The island is less crowded, and accommodation rates start to drop. However, there’s still a risk of hurricanes in September, so it’s wise to monitor the weather if you plan to visit during this month.

In summary, the best time to visit Anna Maria Island for pleasant weather and fewer crowds is during the spring or fall. Winter is great for mild temperatures but can be busy and expensive. Summer is the least crowded but comes with higher temperatures and the potential for rain and storms.

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (27)

Coffee and Wellness?

Coffee and wellness may not seem like an obvious pairing, but when consumed in moderation, coffee can actually be a complementary element of overall wellness by providing potential cognitive, mood-enhancing, and health-promoting benefits.

How Coffee and Wellness are linked:


Coffee is a rich source of antioxidants, such as chlorogenic acid and quinines, which can help combat oxidative stress in the body. Antioxidants play a crucial role in reducing the risk of chronic diseases and promoting overall health.

Improved Cognitive Function

Caffeine, a natural stimulant found in coffee, can enhance alertness, concentration, and mental clarity. Moderate caffeine intake is associated with improved cognitive function and may reduce the risk of cognitive decline and neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer’s.

Mood Enhancement

Coffee can have mood-boosting effects due to its ability to increase the release of neurotransmitters like dopamine and serotonin. Enjoying a cup of coffee can help alleviate feelings of fatigue and promote a more positive mood. I don’t know about you, but when a good quality cup of coffee is in my hand my day is instantly better!

Physical Performance

Caffeine is known to enhance physical performance by increasing adrenaline levels and mobilising fatty acids from fat tissues. Many athletes and fitness enthusiasts use coffee as a pre-workout beverage to improve endurance and stamina.

Weight Management

Caffeine is a common ingredient in many weight loss supplements due to its potential to boost metabolism and promote fat oxidation. It can aid in weight management when combined with a healthy diet and regular exercise.

Reduced Risk of Certain Diseases

Some studies suggest that moderate coffee consumption may be linked to a reduced risk of certain diseases, such as type 2 diabetes, Parkinson’s disease, and certain types of cancer. The antioxidants and bioactive compounds in coffee may contribute to these protective effects.

Social Connection

Enjoying a good cup of coffee with others boosts social connections and reduces feelings of loneliness or isolation, which are essential for overall emotional well-being.

I’m no scientist or doctor but this is the excuse I needed to grab another brew!

With that being said, it’s important to note that naturally the relationship between coffee and wellness depends on moderation.

For most people, moderate coffee intake is usually 3-4 cups per day. Also, the health benefits of coffee tend to vary from person to person!

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (28)


As you can see, Anna Maria Island is not just a destination for beach lovers, it’s a coffee lover’s paradise with tons of amazing places to grab a brew. Whether you’re sipping your latte on a sunny patio, enjoying a donut by the sea, or experiencing the island’s unique coffee culture, Anna Maria Island provides an experience that’s as unforgettable as the coffee itself.

The coffee shops on Anna Maria Island offer not only amazing brews but also a taste of its unique coastal charm, because the coffee scene isn’t just about the exceptional brews; it’s also about the laid-back island lifestyle. The island’s coffee shops offer a place to relax and truly unwind.

I hope you enjoyed this article on the Best Coffee Anna Maria Island – if you have any questions, feel free to leave a comment below!

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (29)

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no additional cost to you, if you make a purchase through any links. This income goes towards the sites running costs and enables me to provide readers with free content.

Best Coffee Anna Maria Island: Happiness in a Cup (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Wyatt Volkman LLD

Last Updated:

Views: 6034

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Wyatt Volkman LLD

Birthday: 1992-02-16

Address: Suite 851 78549 Lubowitz Well, Wardside, TX 98080-8615

Phone: +67618977178100

Job: Manufacturing Director

Hobby: Running, Mountaineering, Inline skating, Writing, Baton twirling, Computer programming, Stone skipping

Introduction: My name is Wyatt Volkman LLD, I am a handsome, rich, comfortable, lively, zealous, graceful, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.